# Accurate Investment Calculator™

How serious are you about investing?

If you are serious then, this investment calculator is for you. Sure, all investment tools published by other sites will tell you how much you'll have after "X" years assuming a "Y" rate of return. But when you use many of these other tools, they don't consider the impact of inflation, taxes or fees on your investment results.

What good is that?

**Not considering these factors is doing investment planning with your fingers crossed and hoping things turn out.** But like I say, my calculators are not toys. Give me the next few minutes, and whether you are investing for income or some future expense, after using this compound growth calculator, you'll finish with a greater insight into your future than you may ever have had. More below

#### Recent changes and enhancements

- Dec. 2023: Charts! Visualize investment or income cash flows.
- Dec. 2023: Export either schedule's data to
**Excel/xlsx**file. Click on "Schedule" then "Continue" or "Skip" past the new title page option. - Dec. 2023: Save either schedule to
**Word/docx**file. Saving to a .docx gives you the opportunity to alter the style of the schedule, to add notes, or incorporate the schedule into a report.

## Getting Started

Click on "Help" for a concise explanation.

First, let's get you oriented to a few of the high-level features of this calculator. Don't be concerned with all the options. We'll discuss each one in the next few minutes.

The upper part of the calculator has two sections. We'll ignore the "Optional Settings" on the right for the time being. Leave those inputs set to zero. When the inputs are all zero, it makes no difference whether the other options are yes or no.

The section labeled "Investment Plan" is the core of the calculator with the first six inputs being the most important ones. If you understand these first six and how they relate, everything else will fall into place.

## A Dual Investment Tool

Notice the choice "Cash Flow Type."

The periodic additions to or withdrawal from the investment collectively is the cash flow. The setting "Cash Flow Type" controls whether the cash flow is an addition to the "Starting Amount" (investment (+)) or a withdrawal from the "Staring Amount" (income (-)). If you select "Income" then set "Starting Amount (PV)" greater than "Goal Amount." Set "Starting Amount" less than "Goal Amount" when you've set "Cash Flow Type" to "Investment."

Frequently one invests so as to have enough saved at some future date to generate an income stream. How much saving will you need to produce the income you desire? This calculator will tell you.

## Investing for Income

Investing for income is a two-step calculation that also happens to demonstrate the flexibility of this calculator.

Follow along, and I'll take you through the steps.

**How much should I have in my investment account when I need to depend on it for income?**

First, how much income do you want?

$3,000 a month.

How long should this income last?

25 years or 300 months.

Set "Cash Flow Type" to "Income."

Enter "Unknown" for "Starting Amount."

Enter 3,000 for "Periodic Withdrawal Amount" (or whatever future income you want).

Enter 300 for "Number of Cash Flows."

Enter an "Annual Rate of Return (ROR)" that is, the rate you think your investment will earn. For this example, we'll use 4.5%.

Set "Goal Amount (FV)" to 0.00. Why? Because we are withdrawing from the investment and we want the income to last for 300 months. When 300 months have passed, we'll have nothing left. Zip. Zero.

You can adjust the dates as needed, but for this example, I have both dates set to May 5th.

Leave the "Investment/Income Frequency" and "Compounding" set to "Monthly."

The calculator is now ready to answer the question, what starting amount do I need to have to receive the desired income for the planned number of months?

Click "Calc", and the answer is **$542,000.00** (rounded up) This is the number we need for step two.

**How much do I have to invest periodically to reach my goal?**

Change the "Cash Flow Type" to "Investment."

Set the "Starting Amount" to whatever the current balance is in your investment account(s). For this example, I'll assume that is 0, so enter 0.00.

Set the "Periodic Investment Amount" to "Unknown."

How much time is remaining before you want to start receiving the income?

Assume 30 years.

How frequently do you want to make additional investments?

Four times a year, or quarterly.

Therefore, for "Number of Cash Flows", enter 120 (4 times a year for 30 years). And set the "Investment/Income Frequency" to "Quarterly."

Set the "Annual Rate of Return" to a value with which you are comfortable. But, you might want to be a bit more aggressive than we were with the "Rate of Return" used in the first calculation. I'm going to use 6% for this example.

Set the "Goal Amount" to **$542,000**. (This is the result of the first calculation).

Set the two dates as needed. If you are following along, I'm leaving "Today's Date" set to May 5th. You can set the "First Cash Flow Date" to when you expect to start making contributions to the investment. If you want to tie the contributions to your pay period, set it to a pay day. I'm going to set it to June 1st.

Click "Calc." The result is $1,636.

Invest **$1,636** every quarter, and if you earn your anticipated rate of return, you'll end up with the required $542,00 after 30 years. Or enough money to give you the income you want.

You can verify the result by clicking on the "Schedule" button and checking the last balance amount.

Cool, right? And we didn't even have to change calculators.

## There's more to this Investment Calculator

What about the "Optional Settings"? How do they work?

Glad you asked.

No doubt if you have done even the most basic reading on investing, you have come across phrases similar to "examples shown do not reflect actual investment results."

A big part of the reason for this is because the investment tools used to create compound growth and investment income illustrations frequently do not consider the impact of taxes, inflation, and potential investment fees.

This calculator will take these important factors into account.

Here's how they work.

## Impact of Inflation on Investing

In the "Optional Settings" section, enter an average "Annual Inflation Rate." If you want to use a rate based on history, the Bureau of Labor Statistics publishes historical US Consumer Price Index data going back to 1914. If you average the CPI for those years, you'll find that in the US, Inflation has averaged 3.2% per year. (Checkout this Inflation Calculator. It will average the CPI for you for any range of years.)

If you enter an assumed inflation rate and set "Adjust Cash Flow for Inflation" to "Yes", then the income or investment cash flows will be adjusted on the first cash flow date after January 1.

The $1,636 quarterly investment from the above example, will have to be increased to a bit over $4,000 a quarter for your investment results to keep pace with inflation.

Even if you don't want to adjust the cash flow for inflation, you may still want to enter an assumed inflation rate. Notice the "Results" pane. If you set "Cash Flow Type" to "Investment", the calculator calculates two inflation-adjusted "Goal Amounts."

"Today's Value After Inflation" is what the goal value will be, expressed in today's dollars when adjusted for inflation. Having $542,000 in 30 years with a 3.2% inflation rate will be as if you had $211,000 today. The other inflation-adjusted result, "Inflation Adjust Goal Amount" is the amount you'll have to have in the future to buy what $542,000 buys today, or per our example, $1,390,000.00.

Notice, if you change the "Cash Flow Type" to "Income", the calculator calculates the inflation-adjusted value for the first "Periodic Withdrawal Amount." If you don't compensate for inflation, and assuming it averages 3% over 25 years, a $3,000 income will be equivalent to having a $1,300 income today, or you'll need to have $6,600 to have the same purchasing power that $3,000 has today.

## Income Taxes and Investing

Obviously, taxes can have a significant impact on your investing results if you pay the taxes due from your investment account. If you are paying taxes using investment funds, then enter your marginal tax rates as needed.

Generally, if an investment is not tax-free, then you would owe taxes on the realized gains. The calculator treats the investment gain (ROI) as realized, and the taxes get deducted on the first cash flow date after the first of each year.

There is an exception. Some investments allow the investor to defer the tax liability. A traditional IRA account comes to mind as such an investment. With these investment accounts, income taxes are calculated on the withdrawal, not on the investment gain.

If you want taxes calculated on the income, set "Taxes Calculated on Withdrawal" to "Yes."

## Fees

Some investments require the investor to pay a fee. Fees get calculated in many ways, and no general purpose investment calculator can accurately handle all scenarios.

This calculator uses the percentage you enter and calculates the amount due using the year's average balance. The fee is deducted at the end of the year.

## Internal Rate of Return (IRR)

How does an investor compare investments and make a decision which investment is best? One consideration is the rate of return. The IRR is the gain an investment generates expressed as an annualized percentage.

You can use this calculation to compare investments. Notice there are two IRR calculations - one before the impact of taxes and fees, and the other after taxes and fees. (If your investment has an irregular cash flow, use this Internal Rate of Return Calculator to calculate the IRR.)

## Solving for an Unknown

The user can quickly answer the following questions with this one calculator.

- What will be the future value of my investments?
- How long will my income last?
- How long will it take to reach my goal?
- What rate of return must I earn to reach my goal?
- What rate of return will create the income I need?
- What will be my income?
- How much do I have to invest to meet my goal?

The Investment Calculator is one of the newer calculators on this site, and I've not had the benefit of much user feedback. Please feel free to comment on how it or this documentation can be improved.

Investments that include regular cash flows can be described by five primary values or attributes. There are other details, but they play a secondary role to these five:

- Present value or starting amount
- Inflow or outflow amount - collectively the cash flow
- Term or number of cash flows
- Rate of Return (ROR) expressed as a percentage
- Future value or ending value (goal amount)

With this calculator, anyone of the five can be "Unknown." The calculator can solve for only one unknown at a time.

Three of the five can be zero, and there are rules for when zero is not appropriate

If the "Cash Flow Type" is set to "Income," the present value can't be zero. There is no money to invest that create the income.

If the "Cash Flow Type" is set to "Investment", the future value can't be zero. Who wants to add to an investment and end up with nothing?

Only one of the five can be zero at a time.

The rate of return and number of cash flows can't be zero.

Thus at least three inputs must be set to a value other than zero. One input may or may not be zero. And one input may be an "Unknown," but is not necessary to have an input set to "Unknown." Frequently, after solving, you may wish to change one of the options and then look at the schedule. The schedule updates whenever you click on the "Schedule" button. It is not necessary to click on "Calc."

## Daryn says:

Is there a calculator I could track 3 separate investments at the same time:

example:

RRSP

TFSA

Company Pension

I like to see what each would be worth in 5 or10 years. Each one would have different amount of contributions over the years.

## Karl says:

If by that you mean 3 separate investments at the same time and keep them separate, the answer is no.

But if they have the same rate-of-return, the problem you have is the different contributions, then you could use Ultimate Financial Calculator. It will allow you to have multiple cash flows with different amounts at different frequencies. Look at the "Investment" cash flow option. If you leave the interest rate set to 0%, it will calculate the ROR based on the contribution and withdrawals.

## Daryn says:

Hi Karl

I was looking for something like this, where i could plug all the numbers in and it would show me what my 3 investment would each be worth. I assume I could do this in the Ultimate Calculator, but only one at a time to get the value. Just wanted to have all 3 show on the same calculator. So from there I could see which one I would start to drawn from first and which ones I would need to reinvest

Investment 1 = RRSP

Open Balance = 20,000

monthly contributions = 1200

average rate earn = 5%

what would the value be in 5 years or 10 years

Investment 2 = Company Penison

Open Balance = 20,000

monthly contributions = 500.00

average rate earn = 6%

what would the value be in 5 years or 10 years

Investment 3 = TFSA

Open balance = 62,500

monthly contributions = 500.00

average rate earn = 4 %

what would the value you be in 5 years or 10 years

## Karl says:

I see. No, I’m afraid the calculator allows for one investment at a time. Of course, you can print out the report and work from that for all 3 at the same time.

## David H says:

I’m a bit confused by what the “Last cash flow date” shows in the results field. I used the calculator to tell me what principal is required to meet a certain monthly income and entered 360 for the “number of cash flows” (i.e. 30 years). I would expect the “Last cash flow date” to reflect the requested 30 years. But instead it reflects various periods (all less than 30 years) depending on the details of what is chosen for inflation rate, ROR, etc.

## Karl says:

I can see how that can be confusing. I need to better document what’s happening.

First, I assume you have the calculator set for income cash flow type.

Set all the optional settings on the upper right to 0.

For the first calculation, if you set "Starting Amount (PV)" to "Unknown," the calculator will calculate the starting amount you need to have to allow for your desired withdrawal amount and the cash flow will last 30 years.

But, if you now change the ROR and do not set the "Starting Amount (PV)" back to "Unknown," and then recalculate, the calculator will adjust the term, not the starting amount. That’s why the ending date will change.

Now, you mentioned the inflation rate option. If you change only that and recalculate, the last cash flow date will not change. What changes is the "Today’s Value After Inflation" amount. What that value tells you is the purchasing power, in today’s dollars of the last cash flow.

Does this help?

## Winggirl Media says:

Hi. Is the Savings Calc working on mobile? I can’t seem to get it to calc when pressing the calc button? Thanks!

## Karl says:

Yes, all plugins work on mobile. Can you send me the URL you are using?

## Winggirl Media says:

Hi in response to your email to me: The url is http://www.starstone.eridanus.co.za Thanks!

## Karl says:

You’re right, on your site, the plugin is not working not mobile (at least on an iPhone). I can’t tell why though. Something is blocking it from loading completely. I can tell this, because when the page loads, notice that there are not any numbers (zeros) populated where the results are displayed.

Take a look at the savings plugin on this using a mobile device, and you’ll see what I mean.

## Alan Hutson says:

I have tried to calculate a retirement income based on a known retirement pot with an assumed rate of return and also an assumed inflation rate, The income is to be withdrawn monthly and the rate of return calculated annually. I set the number of withdrawals as 288 (24 x 12). No taxes were applied and I had added the management fee. The withdrawal amount was left as unknown

When calculated, the calculator gave a much lower number of payments but at a much higher value than I had anticipated. Why was the figure in the number in the periodic returns ignored?

I have used your retirement calculator which is very good but it does not include a inflation or management fee option. As a rough guide I have simply deducted the inflation and management fee percentage from the rate of return to obtain a result. Is this overly simplistic, should I be using this calculator. If so, how do I get it to forecast over the time period that I want?

## Karl says:

First, I’m sorry not to have replied sooner.

The value you enter in the number of periods is not being ignored. The calculator uses it for calculating the initial withdrawal amount which means a withdrawal amount that will enable the initial amount (PV) to last for the number of periods you enter. Then, if you enter an inflation rate, the calculator shows the user the impact that inflation has on the cash flow by shortening the cash flow to make up for the inflation adjustments (increases in the withdrawal amount needed) to maintain the same purchasing power that the initial withdrawal has.

Or from a different perspective, the initial withdrawal amount is not recalculated to a lower value when you enter an inflation rate. When calculating withdrawal and impact of inflation, adjusting the initial calculation would be a circular calculation. If the calculator were to adjust say a $10,000 withdrawal by 4% to maintain the 288 periods, the amount would be lower, but then a 4% adjustment on the lower amount would no longer deplete the PV.

Or at least that’s my thinking now as to why the calculator is programmed this way. It’s been a few years since I designed it and I may have it wrong on why some decisions were made. I would have to do more research if this doesn’t make sense to you.

## Alan Hutson says:

Thanks for your response, perhaps I am misunderstanding the use of the calculation. I am trying to establish what amount I could draw out as a pension income each month to sustain the investment for 24 years if the following notional figures are entered.

Cash Flow -Income

Starting Amount PV – £200,00

Periodic Investment Amount – Unknown

Number of cash flows – 288 (24 years monthly)

ROR -6.8% average over 5 years

Goal amount -£0

Todays date – 10/02/2022

First cash flow – 1/04/2022

Income frequency – Monthly

Compounding – Annually

Inflation – 5%

Adjust – yes

Fed tax 0%

State tax 0%

Taxes deductible – No

Taxes on withdrawal – no

Management fee – 0.48%

The calculator calculates a monthly income of £1389.98 but not for the period entered ie 24 years the result shows that the income will run out on 31/08/2035 a period of 14 years not 24. I was anticipating the monthly income to be in the region of £700.

Am I using the calculator incorrectly or is the calculator not intended for this purpose?

## Karl says:

I may have to get to each question in a few replies. So what I don’t get to now, I’ll get to in a follow-up.

First I have a question for you. How do you arrive at about a £700 monthly income? If the annualized rate-of-return is 6.8%, and the starting value is £200,000, if you divide that by 288 periods, you’ll get £694 which is not allowing anything for the annual return on the principal. At 6.8% you’ll have income on the 200,000 of nearly £1130/month (200,000 * 0.068) / 12. Now I know that’s not the correct math, because it does not allow for compounding and depletion of principal, but £694+£1130 is a lot more than £700.

As a starting point, I eliminated the odd length first period and I set the dates to Mar. 1 (today) and the first cash flow to April 1. I zeroed out the inflation and the fees.

Looking at the schedule, I get a monthly income of £1,385.08 that lasts for 288 periods. After the last withdrawal, the balance is 0. You’ve run out.

Are we good so far? If so, then we can look at the adjustments and see how they impact this.

## Alan Hutson says:

Hello Karl

Yes I agree with you if you zero out inflation taxes and fees The schedule gives the 288 payments of £1385.08with a last cash flow date of 1-03-2046.

The problem arises once 5% annual inflation is added into the calculation, together with an unknown periodic withdrawal amount. The last cash withdrawal is shown as 01-02-2036 rather than 2046 with 167 withdrawals of £1389.21 shown on the cash flow summary. 288 withdrawals were required.

When a 0.45% management fee is added to the 5% inflation the Periodic withdrawal amount remains at £1389.21 with the last cash flow date being 30-09-2035 with 162 payments again not the 288 payments relating to a 24-year period. I was hoping that the calculator would show how much I could withdraw at the start of drawdown for the full 24 years with the inflation adjusted amounts year on year in the schedule.

Previously I used your https://accuratecalculators.com/withdrawal-savings-calculator calculator using the simplistic method of deducting from the 6.8% annual return 5% inflation and 0.45% charges leaving a residual growth of 1.35% and entered this into your calculator. Using a savings figure of £180,000 an unknown withdrawal figure 288 payments and residual 1.35% interest rate with monthly withdrawals and annual compounding, gave a regular withdrawal amount of £729.54 and the withdrawal schedule backed this up. Unfortunately, when I re-entered the figures today, this calculator gave a £NaN.00 result.

I tried your investment calculator as it included the facility to take both inflation and charges into account. Clearly inflation at 5% would have a dramatic effect on 6.8% interest and should have made a significant difference between the income figures with and without inflation & fees which if did not all it did was to reduce the period for which an income could be taken.

I am delighted that you have produced this very useful calculator but I am having difficulties with the results probably due t lack of understanding.

## Karl says:

Alan, I want to let you know, I am working on this. Thanks for letting me know that we agree on the amount calculation of £1385. I was confused by your statement that you expected the monthly income to be about £700.

While rethinking some of the capabilities of this calculator, I noticed a problem that resulted in estimated total taxes and fees showing "NaN" (not a number) rather than the correct result. If you noticed that too, it should be fixed.

Some more details. There are 3 amount calculations involved. First, calculate an unknown amount without the impact of fees or inflation. (If we didn’t agree on this one, then then the other results wouldn’t matter.) The 2nd is the impact on the withdrawal amount due to fees, and the final due to inflation. I’m looking at the impact of fees first because that one should be easier.

To confirm, currently, the calculator does not adjust the withdrawal amount due to fees and inflation. It adjusts the term. I’ll let you know if I make any progress on giving users the option for other adjustments.

## Karl says:

Hi Alan, I believe I have a model that will meet your needs. Assuming the inputs you provided in the earlier message, I see the first withdrawal as being £759.31 (so close to the 700 number) and the final withdrawal at period 288 being £2,767.03. This is after fees. The balance after 288 withdrawals will be 0.05. 🙂

It will be a while before I can get this calculator to support this calculation.

But if you would like me to, I will email you the schedule showing these results.

## Karl says:

Hi Alan, I released the changes to the investment calculator. Now, for income, if the user enters an inflation rate and the withdrawal is unknown, the withdrawal schedule will last as long as the number of periods specified.

You’ll probably notice the initial withdrawal amount is slightly higher than what we had previously discussed. This is because the inflation adjustment happens only on the anniversary date of the initial withdrawal rather than with each withdrawal. I think this model is a little more realistic.

Thank you for suggesting this enhancement. I think it’s a valuable one.

## Alan Hutson says:

Hello Karl,

Thank you very much for your reply and in answer to your question, I would be delighted if you could forward me the schedule you mentioned.

It would be good to have a calculator which adjusts the initial withdrawal amount taking into account the total number of withdrawals required inflation, annual rate of return of the investment and the effect of fees. While inflation and the rate of return are very variable the effect that fee levels can make, are hard to see without this type of calculator.

Thank you again for looking at the issues I raised and look forward to using your revised calculator once you have completed it.

## Karl says:

Sent. Thanks for looking. I think you are right. What you propose would be a useful enhancement.

## Alan Hutson says:

Hello Karl,

I have tried your modified calculator and it works like a dream. It gives exactly the results I was hoping for. This tool enables someone like myself, with limited mathematical abilities, to gain a much better and more realistic appreciation of what retirement income can be drawn down without jeopardising your long tern financial future. It is also possible to quickly see the effects of rate of return, inflation and fees on the available income.

Thank you very much on behalf of myself and probably many more for this brilliant tool. I will be bookmarking this page.

Thanks Again Alan

## Karl says:

Thanks for letting me know Alan. I think it was a timely modification to make, given the up tick in inflation.

## Ramone says:

Good evening,

First of all let me say that I’ve been using this calculator to do investment and income projections for several years now, and I love it!

I hadn’t used it since the updates were applied that changed how the calculator works. A lot has changed, as calculations that I used it to do before, using the EXACT same figures, are now completely off. I’ll ask you to check it out based on these numbers and tell me what you’re getting.

Setting the Calculator up for Income, use the following variables:

Starting Amount: $5,000,000.00

Periodic Withdrawal: $600,000

Number of Cash Flows: 11

Annual Rate of Return: 13.2%

Today’s Date: 07/01/2022

First Cash Flow Date: 07/03/2023

Income Frequency: Annually

Compounding: Monthly

Annual Inflation Rate: 1%

Adjust Cash flow for Inflation: No

Federal Marginal Tax Rate: 35%

State Tax: 0%

State Taxes Deductible: No

Taxes Calculated on Withdrawal: Yes

Management Fee: 1.5%

The results come up, but is missing some info on the schedule:

1. Total net Income is : “$NaN.00”

2. ROR After Taxes/Fees: “NaN.0%”

3. Fees Taxes & Net Income values on the schedule show “NaN.00” for every year except the first year.

I’ve tried different combinations of numbers and settings, but it’s always the same since the update.

Can you look into it please?

Thanks!

## Karl says:

Thank you for taking the time to document this bug. I’m able to reproduce the problem that you’ve reported. I’ll let you know when it is fixed. Hopefully within two weeks.

The problem lies with this option, "Taxes Calculated on Withdrawal." If you set it to "No", the "NaN" (not-a-number) goes away.

## Karl says:

Hi Ramone, the bug is fixed. Once again, thank you for letting me know.

I made a few other small changes that I need to document. The user setting for "Adjust Cash Flow For Inflation" option was not always considered. That too is fixed. This setting impacts how the inflation rate is used. When yes, the cash flow is increased annually. This setting is so users can automatically adjust the cash flow by the assumed inflation rate, When set to "No" the calculated result for "Inflation Adjusted Cash Flow" is the amount the user would need to withdraw or deposit to maintain the equivalent purchasing power as the first cash flow.

NOTE:If you do not see the change right away, you may have to perform a hard refresh of the page:Depending on your operating system all you need to do is the following key combination:

Above, from Refresh Your Cache.

## Maks says:

Hi, your calculator is amazing.. I like the Ultimate Investment Calculator but is there a way I can enter multiple years with different returns instead of compounding returns of one fixed %? that would be awesome.

## Karl says:

Thank you!

Meaning you want the return to change from year to year? If so, then yes. You can select "Rate Change" under "Series" and that will allow you to change the return on any date.

If this is not what you mean, please give me an example.

## Maks says:

Hi Karl,

Thanks for the quick reply. I don’t see the Add series in Rate change. Can you provide the link to the calculator.

Explaining my question with Example:

Initial investment = 1000$

First year return = 10% Ending balance = 1100$

First year additional contribution: 900$ = Ending Balance = 2000$

Second year return = 50% Ending balance = 3000$

Second year additional contribution=1000$

Ending Balance = 4000$

3rd yr Return = -50%

3rd yr End Balance = 2000$

3rd yr withdrawal = 1000$

End balance 1000$

Can I do this with the calculator with all the existing options of this calculator?

## Karl says:

My mistake. I thought you had posted on the Ultimate Financial Calculator page. (I’m working from an administration panel and I don’t see the comments the same way as users see them).

Anyway, please try the above.

## Marco Catano says:

Hi Karl,

What method/calculator would you recommend for calculating the ROI of networking events/tradeshows where sales leads and brand awareness will be primarily obtained?

Thanks

## Karl says:

Hi Marco, sorry it has taken so long to get back to you. This internal rate of return (IRR) calculator calculates an annualized ROI. Any ROI calculation will require you to assign a dollar value to the sales leads and brand awareness. I assume you understand that.

## Marco Catano says:

Thank you, Karl, this is very helpful. Rergards.